2011 Malibu 23 LSV w/555hp or 2012 Axis A22?

[vchili]

Hey everyone, 

I'm like many this year, looking to upgrade their boats and get into wake surfing and was looking at getting myself a first wake boat. Currently have available on the used market around me the following and was curious to hear your opinions for a boat that could give me a good time on the water for surfing, and all around pleasure.  Here are the options I could consider. I'm in Eastern Canada, so really no elevation here and I would likely be in a medium lake, or St-Lawrence river. 

2011 Malibu 23 LSV w/555hp supercharged  engine ~500 hr usage for around $53k
2012 Axis A22 w/LSR 450hp engine ~475 hr of usage for around 46k

There is also perhaps these, but they are getting to be more than I wish to spend... lol
2013 Tige RZ2 with PCM343, 5.7L ~450 hr on it for around $57k
2015 Moomba Mojo Surf Edition for $60k 

What are your opinions on this? Thanks! 

Edited September 21, 2020 by vchili
Updated information